Ralls, TX — August 5, 2025, Peggy Appleton and Terry Appleton were killed in a truck accident at about 11:30 a.m. on U.S. Route 82.
Authorities said a pickup hauling a trailer was heading southwest on U.S. Route 82 when it allegedly ran a stop sign and hit the side of another pickup. Both vehicles caught fire after the crash.
The driver of the second pickup, Hobbs resident Peggy Appleton, 71, was pronounced dead at the scene of the crash, according to authorities. Her husband, Terry Appleton, 78, died hours later after being transported to a local hospital.
The other driver was arrested after the crash and charged with negligent homicide, authorities said.
Authorities have not released any additional information about the Crosby County crash at this time. The accident is still under investigation.
Commentary by Attorney Michael Grossman
When a crash like this makes the news, most people are left wondering: How could someone blow through a stop sign and hit another vehicle with such force that both pickups caught fire? And if the driver has already been charged with negligent homicide, does that mean the investigation is over, or is there still more to uncover?
That’s where things get more complicated than they might seem.
At first glance, it’s tempting to think the arrest answers everything. But in my experience, a criminal charge only scratches the surface of what really happened, and why. What we don’t yet know is what led to the driver of the trailer-hauling pickup allegedly running the stop sign. Was it distraction? Mechanical failure? Impairment? Something else entirely?
We also don’t know what kind of trailer this was, how it was loaded or whether the cargo played any role in the crash or fire. In my line of work, I’ve seen plenty of cases where improperly secured or overweight trailers changed how a pickup handles, especially when braking or turning. That’s not to say cargo caused this wreck, but it’s a factor that needs to be ruled out with evidence, not assumptions.
Beyond that, several unanswered questions remain:
- Was the driver using a cell phone?
- Did the vehicle have dash cameras or GPS logs?
- Was this driver working for a company at the time, or hauling in a personal capacity?
- If it was work-related, who maintained the trailer and who was responsible for the driver’s training and oversight?
Each of those details could shape how accountability is assigned, and these questions won’t be answered without a thorough investigation that goes beyond what law enforcement typically has the time or resources to do.
In a similar case I handled, a driver ran a stop sign at night while pulling a flatbed loaded with a massive piece of steel. The steel wasn’t properly secured or lit, and though the crash looked at first like driver error, we later uncovered multiple companies who helped create the conditions for that wreck. Without digging deeper, none of that would have come to light.
The same principle applies here. Just because someone’s been charged doesn’t mean we have the full picture. If anything, that’s the start, not the end, of figuring out how this happened and who needs to answer for it.
Key Takeaways:
- A criminal charge doesn’t explain why a driver ran a stop sign or what led up to it.
- Trailer type, cargo load and vehicle condition are key pieces of the puzzle that remain unknown.
- Cell phone records, dash cams and GPS data may be critical in understanding what the driver was doing.
- If the pickup was being used for work, there may be broader questions of employer responsibility.
- Getting to the truth takes more than a police report. It takes detailed evidence and a willingness to look beyond the obvious.
call us 
Email Us 
Text us