Vanderburgh County, IN — September 19, 2025, Pamela Appel was killed in a truck accident at about 8:30 a.m. on State Road 62/West Lloyd Expressway.
Authorities said a semi-truck and an SUV collided at the intersection of Lloyd Expressway and McDowell Road.
SUV driver Pamela J. Appel, 72, died after being transported to a local hospital, according to authorities.
The truck driver was not hurt, authorities said.
Authorities have not released any additional information about the Vanderburgh County crash at this time.
Commentary by Attorney Michael Grossman
When people hear that a crash between a semi-truck and an SUV ended with one driver dead and the other walking away, they naturally want answers. How did this happen? Who’s responsible? And most importantly, are we getting the whole story?
Based on what’s been reported so far, we know that a semi-truck and an SUV collided at the intersection of Lloyd Expressway and McDowell Road. The SUV driver passed away after being taken to the hospital, while the truck driver was uninjured. Beyond that, the public record is basically silent.
That’s a problem. Because without knowing who had the right of way, whether either vehicle was speeding or if the truck was turning, stopped or running a red light, it’s impossible to understand what really happened. It’s not even clear from the reporting which vehicle struck the other, an essential detail in piecing together liability.
This lack of information leaves wide open the question of fault. Some might assume the SUV driver caused the crash, while others might blame the trucker. But no fair conclusion can be reached without investigating the evidence. That includes things like dash camera footage, engine control module data and traffic light sequencing. Cell phone records might show if either driver was distracted, and in-cab cameras, if they exist, could help clarify how the crash unfolded in real time.
I’ve handled enough of these cases to know that a crash like this often isn’t the result of a single bad decision but a chain of oversights, and not always just by the drivers involved. Trucking companies play a major role here too. What kind of training did the truck driver have? What were their hiring procedures like? Did the company take shortcuts that put an unqualified driver behind the wheel of an 80,000-pound vehicle?
The bottom line is this: crashes involving commercial trucks demand serious scrutiny. Not just to assign blame, but to understand what went wrong and who had the power to prevent it. That doesn’t happen automatically. It takes evidence, expertise and an investigation that goes beyond what police reports can usually offer.
Key Takeaways:
- There are major unanswered questions about how this crash occurred and who had the right of way.
- The fact that the truck driver was uninjured while the SUV driver died may not reflect fault. It just highlights the size disparity between vehicles.
- Critical evidence likely exists in dash cams, ECM data and traffic signal timing, but hasn’t been reported.
- The truck driver’s training, qualifications and company oversight are all potential factors that should be investigated.
- Determining accountability requires a thorough, independent investigation, not assumptions based on early news reports.
call us 
Email Us 
Text us