Collier County, FL — December 12, 2025, one person was killed and two others were injured in a multi-truck accident at about 12:10 a.m. on Interstate 75/Alligator Alley.
Authorities said a southbound semi-truck stopped near mile marker 96 because of limited visibility caused by smoke from a prescribed burn at Picayune Strand State Forest. It was hit from behind by a second semi-truck, causing a chain reaction that damaged another semi-truck, a GMC pickup, a Chevrolet pickup and an Audi sedan.
The 52-year-old Madeira Beach man driving the Chevrolet pickup died from injuries suffered in the crash, according to authorities, while two passengers were hospitalized with serious injuries.
The Audi driver suffered minor injuries, authorities said, but no other injuries were reported.
Authorities have not released any additional information about the Collier County crash at this time. The accident is still under investigation.
Commentary by Attorney Michael Grossman
When multiple 18-wheelers crash in the middle of the night, people naturally want to know: How does something like this happen? Who’s supposed to be keeping these trucks from crashing into each other? And in this case, was the low visibility the only factor, or were mistakes made by one or more drivers?
Right now, we’re told that one semi-truck stopped on I-75 near mile marker 96 due to smoke from a prescribed burn nearby. Another semi rear-ended it, kicking off a chain reaction that involved several vehicles and left one person dead. That raises an important legal question: Was the first truck stopped in a safe and lawful manner? Or was it effectively blocking the road without warning to those behind it?
Depending on whether that truck was still moving or fully stopped, the legal analysis changes. If it was stopped in a live lane of traffic, visibility becomes a central issue. Did the driver engage hazard lights? Was the truck equipped with reflective markings and operational tail lights? Those details matter when assessing whether following drivers had any meaningful chance to react.
Then there’s the second truck, the one that crashed into the back of the first. We don’t yet know if that driver was following too closely, speeding or simply failed to account for the smoke ahead. But these are precisely the kinds of questions that a proper investigation can answer by looking at dash cam footage, engine control module (ECM) data and possibly in-cab camera recordings. Was the driver fatigued or distracted? Was the crash avoidable with proper vigilance?
One of the most overlooked parts of these investigations is what the trucking companies themselves were doing behind the scenes. Did they have policies in place for driving in low visibility? Were their drivers trained on how to handle sudden smoke conditions? And, crucially, were any of these drivers operating on tight delivery schedules that pressured them to take risks?
In one of my past cases, a trucking company hired a driver who had already been fired from multiple other jobs and put her on the road with barely any screening. She went on to cause a crash that never should have happened. What looked like driver error was actually a failure that began in the company’s hiring office. That’s why I always say that crashes like this rarely come down to one bad decision. They’re the result of multiple layers of negligence that start long before the wreck.
We also can’t ignore that this crash happened in smoke from a controlled burn. That raises additional concerns about whether proper notice was given to the public, and whether visibility conditions were adequately communicated to those traveling on the road that night. Those details fall outside the trucking companies’ control, but they may still shape how responsibility is ultimately assigned.
Key Takeaways:
- Whether the lead semi was stopped or moving makes a critical difference in how fault is evaluated.
- Black box data, dash cams and driver phone records will be essential in determining what really happened.
- Following distance, speed and driver attentiveness are all factors that must be investigated.
- Trucking company policies on driver training, scheduling and route planning may have played a role.
- Environmental conditions like smoke matter, but they don’t automatically excuse negligent driving.
call us 
Email Us 
Text us