McKinney, TX — September 28, 2025, Mel Cruz, Pilar Cruz and Sherita Turner were injured in a car accident at about 1:15 p.m. on F.M. 2478/Custer Road.
A preliminary accident report indicates that a northbound 2016 Ford Edge collided with a southbound 2024 Tesla Model 3 while turning left onto Carolina Wren Way.
Tesla driver Mel Cruz, 68, and passenger Pilar Cruz, 65, were seriously injured in the crash, according to the report.
Ford driver Sherita Turner, 55, was seriously injured as well, the report states.
Authorities have not released any additional information about the Collin County crash at this time.
Commentary by Attorney Michael Grossman
After any serious crash, there’s a moment where people naturally wonder what really happened. It’s one thing to have a police report, but those only tell part of the story. The deeper truth often lies in the pieces that aren’t immediately obvious, and those are the ones that matter most in the long run.
Did the authorities thoroughly investigate the crash? Any time a vehicle makes a left turn across traffic and a collision follows, it raises serious questions about timing, visibility and driver decisions. But that doesn’t mean the case is simple. A quality investigation should map out the scene with precision, using tools like laser measurements or detailed reconstructions, to piece together each vehicle’s path. It’s not clear if investigators in this case had the training or time to go that far. That’s concerning because even small oversights in measuring impact points or analyzing turn angles can drastically change how fault is understood.
Has anyone looked into the possibility that a vehicle defect caused the crash? On the surface, people often assume these types of crashes are purely about driver judgment. But both the Ford and Tesla involved here are vehicles with complex systems. A steering issue, delayed braking response or even a sensor error in the Tesla’s assisted-driving features could be relevant. These things don’t always leave obvious clues at the scene, which makes a detailed mechanical inspection critical. It’s unclear whether either vehicle was examined that way, and without that step, some important facts might go unnoticed.
Has all the electronic data relating to the crash been collected? With modern vehicles, especially a 2024 Tesla, there’s a wealth of electronic data available that could help explain what happened in the moments before impact. Things like braking logs, turn signals, steering input or even the use of assisted driving modes can be pulled from the car’s systems. Add in possible phone data or traffic camera footage, and you get a much fuller picture. But this kind of digital investigation takes effort and coordination. If no one is asking for that data, key parts of the story may never surface.
When the only story told is the one visible at the roadside, critical pieces of the truth get left behind. These kinds of crashes are rarely as straightforward as they first seem, and the difference between assumption and understanding often comes down to whether someone was willing to ask harder questions.
Key Takeaways:
- Serious crashes deserve more than just surface-level investigations.
- Vehicle defects can play a role even when there’s no obvious sign.
- Electronic data from modern cars can be the key to understanding what really happened.
call us 
Email Us 
Text us