UPDATE (November 18, 2024): Recently-released reports clarify some further details about what happened leading up to and during this accident.

According to these reports, a Kenworth 18-wheeler that had been traveling northwest on I.H. 81 collided with the rear-end of a Peterbilt 18-wheeler. The impact led the Kenworth to become jackknifed. Following that, a Subaru Outback crashed into the back of the Peterbilt as well. That collision caused the Subaru to veer left, leading to another collision between it and a Hyundai Elantra. The Elantra reportedly caught fire over the course of the accident, as well.

27-year-old James Stokes, who was reportedly riding as a passenger in the Outback, sustained fatal injuries due to the wreck. 23-year-old Neekimu Jardim Jr., driving the Outback, may have been injured; 52-year-old Peterbilt driver Richard Bonilla reportedly suffered minor injuries. Both Bonilla and Jardim were transported to local medical facilities by EMS in order to receive necessary evaluation and treatment. No additional details are currently available. The investigation continues.

East Hanover Twp., PA — November 15, 2024, James Stokes was killed in a four-vehicle truck accident at approximately 2:45 a.m. along I.H. 81.

According to authorities, the accident took place in the northbound lanes of Interstate Highway 81 in the vicinity of the S.H. 743 exit.

James Stokes Killed, Neekimu Jardim Jr., Richard Bonilla Injured in Truck Accident on I.H. 81 in Lebanon County, PA

The cause of the accident remains unclear. Officials indicate that, for as yet unknown reasons, a collision took place between four separate vehicles, two of which were apparently 18-wheelers. 27-year-old James Stokes—who had reportedly been a passenger in one of the passenger vehicles—suffered fatal injuries as a result of the wreck, according to reports. Additional details pertaining to this incident are not available at this point in time. The investigation is currently ongoing.

Commentary by Attorney Michael Grossman

Multi-vehicle accidents involving large commercial trucks, like this one, often present complicated questions about how the crash unfolded and who may bear responsibility. With new details revealing the sequence of events, including the initial rear-end collision between two 18-wheelers and the chain reaction that followed, it’s clear that a thorough investigation is essential to understanding what caused this tragic outcome.

A key area of focus should be the circumstances surrounding the Kenworth’s collision with the Peterbilt. Rear-end collisions involving commercial vehicles can often point to issues such as driver distraction, fatigue, or improper speed. Investigators will need to examine whether the Kenworth driver was paying attention to the road and adhering to safe driving practices. Additionally, reviewing data from the truck’s Electronic Logging Device (ELD) and event recorders could provide critical insight into whether the driver’s hours of service or reaction times played a role in the crash.

Another important aspect to investigate is whether mechanical issues contributed to the Kenworth’s inability to stop in time. Commercial trucks are required to undergo regular maintenance, and any lapse in that upkeep—such as worn brakes or faulty tires—could point to negligence on the part of the trucking company or a third-party maintenance provider. Similarly, the Peterbilt’s condition must also be reviewed to rule out whether its position or functionality played any role in the initial collision.

The fire involving the Hyundai Elantra adds another layer of complexity to the investigation. Fires in accidents are not always unavoidable; they can result from design flaws in vehicles, improperly secured cargo, or other preventable issues. Forensic analysis of the Elantra will be necessary to determine whether its design or maintenance contributed to the fire and the overall severity of the crash.

Ultimately, the goal is to uncover the truth and provide answers to those affected by the accident. Even if it requires conducting an independent investigation to obtain critical evidence, it’s essential to consider every factor to ensure that those impacted by the accident receive the clarity and closure they deserve.

Explore cases we take