Update (February 6, 2025): Authorities have identified the two people killed in this crash as Fabian Zamora, 31, and Carolina Navarette de Leal, 49. Zamora was the repair truck driver, while de Lear was driving the Toyota.

Palm Desert, CA — February 4, 2025, two people were killed in a truck accident at about 1 p.m. on Interstate 10/Sono Bono Memorial Freeway.

Authorities said a Toyota sedan was traveling west in the center lane of I-10 near Washington Street when it crashed into a semi-truck in the right line, then hit another semi-truck that had been parked on the shoulder. The first semi involved in the crash hit a tire repair truck that had been parked in front of the disabled truck.

Fabian Zamora, Carolina Navarette de Leal Killed in Truck Accident in Palm Desert, CA

The Toyota driver and the repair truck driver, who was a pedestrian at the time of the crash, died at the scene, according to authorities. Their names have not been made public at this time.

Authorities have not released any additional information about the crash at this point.

The accident is still under investigation.

Commentary by Attorney Michael Grossman

Crashes involving multiple vehicles, especially on highways, tend to raise more questions than answers. In this case, a car collided with a moving semi-truck, then hit a parked one, and that set off a chain reaction involving a repair truck. Right now, it’s unclear what led to the initial crash, but one thing is certain: figuring out exactly what happened will require looking beyond the crash scene.

A key question in this case is why the Toyota driver lost control. Did another vehicle’s actions force them into the truck’s lane? Was there a mechanical failure? The only way to answer these questions is by reviewing available evidence, such as traffic camera footage, dashcam video from nearby vehicles and data from the Toyota’s onboard systems.

Another critical issue is the parked semi-truck. Trucks don’t just pull over on the shoulder for no reason. There was a tire repair truck in front of it, meaning the driver likely stopped due to a mechanical issue. That raises important legal questions. Did the truck driver take proper steps to make their stopped vehicle visible to others? Were hazard lights on? Did they set out reflective warning triangles as required by federal law? If those precautions weren’t followed, then the parked truck may have played a bigger role in this crash than it appears.

There’s also the issue of the first semi-truck’s movement. The reports say the Toyota hit a moving truck first before hitting the parked one. That means investigators need to look at what the moving truck was doing at the moment of impact. Did the Toyota drift into the lane, or did the truck change lanes without seeing the smaller car? Engine control module (ECM) data from the semi-truck could help answer that, as it records speed, braking and other key details.

Finally, it’s worth asking whether the repair worker had adequate protection. Roadside workers face serious risks when assisting broken-down vehicles, and there are procedures in place to help keep them safe. The investigation should determine whether those precautions were followed, and if not, why.

At this point, there are too many unknowns to say who was primarily at fault for this crash. But if authorities don’t go beyond the crash scene and dig into all the available evidence, some of those questions may never be answered.

Explore cases we take