Analyzing the Semi Crash on I-81 in Schuylkill County, PA

Michael GrossmanSeptember 03, 2025 2 minutes

An 81-year-old man, Esau Foster, was killed in a collision with a semi-truck on I-81 northbound in Butler Township. According to authorities, the crash happened at mile marker 119.4 around 2:22 p.m. on September 2. Foster was taken to Lehigh Valley Hospital–Cedar Crest, where he was pronounced dead later that evening. The truck driver’s condition has not been released, and investigators from the Frackville Barracks are continuing to review the case.

When a crash between a passenger vehicle and a semi-truck results in a fatality, investigators must take a close look at what factors led up to the collision, including driver condition, truck maintenance, and other circumstances.

Could Driver Fatigue or Distraction Have Contributed?

Semi-truck crashes often raise concerns about whether the driver was fully alert at the time of impact. Investigators will likely review the trucker’s hours-of-service records to determine whether they had been driving for too long without rest. They may also look at phone records, in-cab video, or GPS data to confirm whether distraction played a role. Witness statements could help establish whether the truck drifted lanes, braked late, or appeared to react suddenly before the collision.

Was a Mechanical Issue a Factor?

Investigators will also need to examine whether the truck’s braking system, tires, or steering components contributed to the crash. If a mechanical failure prevented the driver from slowing or maneuvering, that could point to maintenance oversights or even defective equipment. Reviewing inspection logs and service records will help confirm whether the truck was roadworthy at the time of the crash.

What Evidence Should Be Examined?

Key evidence will include Engine Control Module (ECM) data from the semi-truck, which can provide second-by-second information on speed, braking, and throttle input. Physical evidence at the scene, such as skid marks, vehicle damage, and debris distribution, will also help reconstruct the sequence of events. Traffic cameras or dashcam footage may provide additional context.

Why the Investigation Is Important

A fatal crash on a major interstate involving a semi-truck demands a detailed review. Establishing whether fatigue, distraction, or a mechanical issue contributed will be essential for accountability. The investigation will provide critical answers about how this collision occurred and why it happened in the first place.