What Led to the Three-Vehicle Crash in Bruce Township, MI?

Michael GrossmanFebruary 11, 2025 2 minutes

A three-vehicle crash involving two semi-trucks and a passenger vehicle in northern Macomb County left two people hospitalized Thursday morning. According to reports, the crash occurred around 10:15 a.m. at 34 Mile and Van Dyke in Bruce Township. Law enforcement confirmed that the passenger vehicle was crushed between the two semi-trucks, causing non-life-threatening injuries to both occupants. While the exact cause of the crash remains under investigation, authorities noted that winter weather had created slick road conditions in the area.

Whenever I hear about crashes like this involving passenger vehicles and large trucks, I think about how critical it is to determine whether the truck drivers were operating safely for the conditions. In my experience, when a semi-truck fails to stop in time or loses control, the consequences can be severe for those in smaller vehicles.

Was the Semi-Truck Driver Behind the Vehicle Driving Safely for the Conditions?

Semi-trucks require much greater stopping distances than passenger vehicles, especially when roads are slick. Investigators should determine whether the truck driver behind the passenger vehicle was following too closely or traveling too fast for the icy conditions. Even if a truck is within the posted speed limit, it may still be too fast for safe operation when roads are hazardous. Additionally, investigators should review whether the trucks had properly maintained tires designed for winter driving.

Could a Mechanical Issue Have Contributed?

A critical factor to examine is whether mechanical issues played a role in this crash. If a truck’s brakes were not properly maintained, stopping distances could have been compromised. Investigators should review maintenance records for both semi-trucks to determine whether they were in proper working condition. Additionally, data from each truck’s Engine Control Module (ECM) could reveal whether the driver behind the passenger vehicle attempted to brake before the impact or if there was a mechanical failure.

What Evidence Needs to Be Examined?

A full investigation should include reviewing ECM data from both trucks, maintenance records, and any available dashcam footage. Surveillance cameras from nearby businesses or traffic lights may also provide insight into how the crash unfolded. Additionally, statements from witnesses and accident reconstruction experts can help determine whether the trucks were following too closely or failed to stop in time due to driver error or mechanical failure.

Why a Thorough Investigation Is Needed in These Kinds of Crashes

For the victims of this crash, understanding what happened is essential. Determining whether the truck drivers were following safe driving practices or if mechanical failures played a role can help provide clarity and ensure accountability. In my experience, these types of investigations often uncover contributing factors that aren’t immediately obvious but are crucial in understanding the full picture of the crash.