Examining the 53-Vehicle Pileup on I-40 in Orange County, NC

Michael GrossmanFebruary 20, 2025 2 minutes

A chain-reaction crash on Interstate 40 West during a snowstorm left one person dead and involved at least 53 vehicles. According to authorities, the initial collisions on I-40 and I-85 caused traffic to back up before a tractor-trailer struck another vehicle from behind, triggering a series of crashes. The driver of the semi-truck was arrested and charged with misdemeanor death by vehicle and exceeding a safe speed for conditions. Another individual, identified as 78-year-old Jerolyn Day Wilson, was killed as a result of the crash.

Whenever I hear about a crash like this, I think about whether the commercial truck driver adjusted their driving for the hazardous conditions. Large vehicles require significantly longer stopping distances, and when visibility and traction are compromised, failing to slow down appropriately can have devastating consequences.

Was the Semi-Truck Traveling Too Fast for the Conditions?

Authorities charged the truck driver with exceeding a safe speed, which suggests that he may not have adjusted his driving for the snowstorm. While the posted speed limit might be legal in clear conditions, trucking regulations require commercial drivers to reduce speed when road conditions are hazardous. Investigators will need to determine whether the truck driver failed to account for limited visibility, icy roads, or slowed traffic ahead.

Was the Truck Properly Maintained for Winter Driving?

Another key question is whether the semi-truck was properly equipped for the winter storm. Investigators should review maintenance records to determine if the truck’s tires had adequate tread depth and if the braking system was functioning correctly. A mechanical failure, such as worn brakes or poor tire grip, could have played a role in the driver’s inability to stop in time.

What Evidence Should Be Reviewed?

To fully understand what led to this crash, investigators should analyze the truck’s Engine Control Module (ECM) data, which could reveal how fast the truck was traveling, whether the brakes were applied, and whether the driver made any evasive maneuvers. Surveillance footage, dashcam recordings, and eyewitness statements can also provide insight into how the crash unfolded.

Why This Investigation Matters

Crashes involving large commercial vehicles in hazardous weather often raise critical safety concerns. In my experience, investigating whether a truck driver followed safe driving practices or if mechanical issues contributed to the collision can be essential in determining accountability. A full investigation will help ensure that those affected understand exactly what happened and why.